Home Does a Walmart Slip and Fall Injury Need Surgery to Be Worth Money?

Does a Walmart Slip and Fall Injury Need Surgery to Be Worth Money?

Reading Time: 8 Minutes

November 21, 2025Elvis Goren

Exterior photo of a Walmart store at sunset, capturing the building, parking lot, and warm evening light.

If you slipped and fell at Walmart, you’re likely facing two main worries right now. The first is the pain, of course, and the medical bills. The second is the big question: “Will Walmart actually pay me for this, even if I don’t need surgery?”

Many people think a personal injury claim only has value if the victim’s injuries require surgical intervention. Not true. Your injury does not need to be severe enough for surgery to result in a meaningful settlement.

The value of your Walmart slip and fall claim depends on one thing far more than the type of medical treatment: documentation. We focus on proving that Walmart was negligent and that your injury is real, which includes everything from sprains and strains to concussions or fractures that heal with a cast.

Settlements for these non-surgical injuries commonly fall in the $15,000 to $100,000+ range, with clear-liability cases sometimes reaching even higher amounts.

What is the actual payout for a non-surgical slip and fall at Walmart?

It’s tough to give an exact “average” because every single case is different. Your case value is a mix of your specific injury and the facts about what Walmart did wrong.

For non-surgical injuries like moderate fractures, serious sprains, or a non-operative herniated disc, settlements can range from $10,000 to over $150,000 nationwide. The majority of non-surgical cases tend to settle between $15,000 and $75,000.

Here is what decides if you land on the high or low end of that range:

Objective Evidence: Did you get an MRI, X-ray, or CT scan? Diagnostic imaging that clearly documents an injury (like a ligament tear or a disc bulge) is incredibly valuable, often boosting settlements by 30-400%. This evidence replaces surgery as proof of the injury’s severity.
Consistency of Treatment: Did you go to the doctor immediately? Have you attended all your physical therapy or specialist appointments? Gaps in treatment can be used by the insurance company to argue your injury isn’t serious, potentially lowering your settlement offer by 30-50%.
Lost Wages: Clear documentation of missed work and lost income adds quantifiable value to your claim.
The Multiplier: Insurance companies and lawyers use a simple formula: Economic Damages (medical bills + lost wages) multiplied by a number, or multiplier. This multiplier, which ranges from 1.5 to 5, determines your pain and suffering compensation. More serious injuries that require long-term physical therapy and cause chronic pain get a higher multiplier.

Why Does Where You Fell in California Matter?

In California, you have a crucial advantage other states don’t have: pure comparative negligence.

Many states will prevent you from recovering anything if a jury decides you were more than 50% at fault for your own fall. But California allows you to recover damages even if you were 99% at fault. Your final compensation simply gets reduced by your percentage of fault. This system is a powerful negotiating tool for your attorney because Walmart cannot use the blame game to completely wipe out your claim.

What is Claims Management, Inc. (CMI), and how does Walmart use it?

Walmart is what we call “self-insured,” and they use their own third-party claims management company called Claims Management, Inc., or CMI. You won’t be dealing with a typical insurance company.

CMI’s entire purpose is to investigate and administer claims against Walmart, but in reality, they operate with a clear mandate: to minimize or deny payouts. They are not a neutral party. You should never trust a CMI representative.

Quick Hits: CMI’s Common Tactics to Avoid Payment

Recorded Statements: CMI will immediately press you for a recorded statement, making it sound mandatory. Do not give one. There is zero benefit to you, and CMI’s representatives are experts at getting you to say something they can use against you later, like admitting you were rushing or looking at your phone.
False Promises: They may promise to “take care of” your medical bills if you cooperate. They almost never actually agree to pay anything upfront. Instead, they use your bills and medical records to build a file that argues your injuries are pre-existing or less severe than you claim.
Delay and Denial: CMI is known for delaying the process and looking for reasons to deny liability entirely. They will often argue they had no “constructive notice” of the hazard, claiming the spill or object was only on the floor for a few seconds before your fall.

Because CMI is systematic in its defense, you need an attorney who can immediately send a preservation letter for the surveillance footage and witness statements. That is how you level the playing field.

Walmart’s own Environmental, Health, and Safety Statement commits them to complying with applicable EHS laws and other requirements, including protecting the health and safety of their associates and customers.

They commit to creating a safe place to work and shop [link to policies] to build trust with everyone who walks through the doors, which makes their systematic defense strategy even more problematic.

How long does it actually take to settle a slip and fall case with Walmart?

Dealing with a large corporation like Walmart means you should expect a systematic process, which takes time. Your case will rarely be solved in a few weeks. The timeline is usually determined by how long it takes you to reach Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI).

MMI is the point where your condition has stabilized, and further treatment is unlikely to make things significantly better. Your doctor determines this, and it is the absolute worst time to settle.

Simple, clear-liability cases (minor sprain, full recovery): A few months.
Moderate non-surgical cases (fracture in a cast, extended physical therapy): 6 to 12 months. This is the most common timeframe.
Complex or contested cases (contested liability, chronic pain): 12 to 24+ months, especially if a lawsuit has to be filed.

You must wait until MMI because if you settle too early, you lose the right to ask for more money later. That means you would pay out of pocket for any unexpected, ongoing treatment.

What medical evidence makes a non-surgical case valuable?

Since you don’t have a surgical bill to establish high value, the strength of your case rests on the quality of your medical records and your consistency in treatment.

Key Evidence to Strengthen a Non-Surgical Claim

Diagnostic Imaging: Make sure your medical providers order an MRI or CT scan if your pain persists. These tests show soft tissue damage, like an annular tear or nerve impingement, which an X-ray can’t. Clear imaging findings make it much harder for CMI to claim your injury is just a minor sprain.
Physical Therapy Notes: Physical therapy sessions document your functional limitations and pain progression. A course of 8 to 12 weeks of consistent physical therapy can total $1,800 to over $7,000 in bills, which drastically increases your economic damages and, therefore, your final settlement.
Specialist Consultations: Seeing a specialist like an orthopedic doctor or a neurologist, even if they recommend conservative care rather than surgery, confirms the severity of your condition.
Personal Pain Journal: Keep a record of your daily pain levels, how the injury stops you from doing everyday things (like picking up your child, driving, or working), and the emotional toll. This journal helps your attorney quantify your “pain and suffering,” which is a major part of your compensation.

You Don’t Have to Fight Walmart Alone.

You’re dealing with pain, lost income, and the worry of medical debt. That is enough for one person. Fighting a massive company like Walmart, which has its own corporate claims management team (CMI), only adds stress to an already traumatic situation.

Your non-surgical injury is serious. The law agrees.

We focus on helping you build the strongest possible case by preserving evidence, navigating CMI’s tactics, and leveraging California’s favorable laws. Your situation isn’t hopeless. Getting clear legal guidance is the first step toward reclaiming control.

Don’t let a corporate claims adjuster dictate the value of your case. Call DK Law today for a free consultation.

About the Author

Elvis Goren

Elvis Goren is the Organic Growth Manager at DK Law, bringing over a decade of content and SEO expertise from Silicon Valley startups to the legal industry. He champions a human-first approach to legal content, crafting fun and engaging resources that make complex injury law topics resonate with everyday readers while driving meaningful organic growth.